video poster image

Welcome to

Hutsenpiller

Insurance

We are a local, family-owned independent insurance agency that blends the expertise of local insurance agents with cutting-edge technology to offer our clients an effortless and stress-free insurance experience. From personalized guidance to seamless processes, we're here to make every step simple and convenient for you.

Get A Quote

How can we help today?

Get a quote

Looking for a new quote or just want to see what options you have? This is the place to start!
 
 
Get Started

Service Your Account

Need help with an existing policy? Our team is ready to assist you with anything you need.
 
 
 
Service
video poster image
Insurance Built on Local Roots, Designed for your Convenience
 

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we’re dedicated to delivering an insurance experience that’s simple, personalized, and rooted in our Tennessee community. Since 1992, we’ve proudly served our neighbors, combining decades of expertise with a commitment to making your life easier.

Our promise to you? To stay true to our values: working harder, communicating clearly, and consistently exceeding your expectations.

A Legacy of Family and Community

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we’re more than just a business—we’re a family. For generations, we’ve built our agency on values that matter: trust, integrity, and genuine dedication to our community. From the moment you reach out to us, we aim to provide a personalized experience that feels less like “just insurance” and more like being cared for by someone who truly has your back.

Your satisfaction isn’t just a goal; it’s our legacy. We’ve worked hard to create a company where every customer feels like part of our family, and we wouldn’t have it any other way. Whether you’re protecting your home, car, or loved ones, you can count on us to treat you with the same care and attention we’d give our own.

Meet Our Team
Shea&CJ Transparent
CJ & Shea Hutsenpiller

Local agents serving all of Tennessee.

 

yjyt
cd
hty
Nationwide-Insurance-Logo
travelers
geico logo
openly logo
wd
kpko

Our promise to our clients...

  • We Work Hard for You 💪

    At Hutsenpiller Insurance, hard work isn’t just a mindset—it’s a way of life. Our team wakes up early (yes, we open at 6 AM!) and stays dedicated to making your insurance experience effortless. Whether you need quick answers, a fast quote, or someone to help you navigate a tricky situation, we’re here to roll up our sleeves and get it done. You deserve an insurance agency that’s as invested in your peace of mind as you are.

  • We Keep You in the Loop 🔁

    Insurance can be confusing, but it doesn’t have to feel that way. We believe communication is key to making your experience smooth and stress-free. Whether it’s a quick email, a helpful text, or walking you through the details of a claim, we’ll be with you every step of the way. No more wondering or guessing—we’re here to make sure you always know what’s going on and what to expect. Because when it comes to your peace of mind, clarity is everything. 

  • We Deliver More Than Expected 🎉

    Sure, technology is great (and we use plenty of it to make things easier), but we know nothing beats the care of a real person who truly has your back. At Hutsenpiller, we use cutting-edge tools to speed things up, but we never lose sight of the human touch. From finding you the best options to helping you protect what matters most, we’re all about exceeding your expectations. Fast, friendly, and thoughtful service—it’s what we’re known for, and it’s what you deserve.

caricon
0 +
Vehicles Insured
houseemojiii
0 +
Homes Insured
star
0 +
Client Testimonials
tristarr
0 +
Years in Business
irwin

Emma D.
Lebanon, TN

"CJ & his team have been great to work with! I'm a new client and they have been very attentive and quick to respond with any questions! Plus, I'm saving money and getting extra bonuses to my coverage than before!"

John Griffin

John G.
Mt. Juliet, TN

"Good people. Good location. Honest & reliable. Family/Locally owned. Customers come first with this group. Love that they shop rates for me. One of the best in Middle Tennessee!"

rick blair

Rick B.
Mt. Juliet, TN

"I have been a customer of Hutsenpiller Insurance for almost a decade now. CJ & the staff are personable, professional, and extremely efficient. "

Switching made simple.

Changing your insurance shouldn’t be a headache—it should be easy, seamless, and stress-free. At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we take care of every detail so you don’t have to. From canceling your old policy to contacting lienholders, we handle it all with care and precision. You can sit back and relax, knowing that every step of the process is in good hands.

Here’s how we make it happen:

  • 📋 We cancel your old policies for you.
  • 🏠 We contact your mortgage and lienholders on your behalf.
  • ✅ We ensure everything is handled smoothly, start to finish.

Let us handle the details while you enjoy the peace of mind. It's what we do best!

 

READY TO GET STARTED?

Step 1: Request a quote

Getting started couldn’t be simpler! Whether you prefer to visit us in person for a friendly face-to-face chat or handle everything online from the comfort of your home, we’ve got you covered. Just let us know what you need, and we’ll take care of the rest.

Get a quote

Step 2: Review & Compare

We’ll provide you with personalized quotes tailored to your needs and walk you through how they compare to your current coverage. Whether you’re looking for better protection, savings, or both, our team is here to make sure you find the perfect fit.
 
 
Meet our Agents

Step 3: Give us the green light

Once you’re ready to make the switch, all you have to dois let us know. We’ll handle everything—setting up your new policy, canceling your old one, and even notifying any lienholders or other parties on your behalf. Sit back, relax, and enjoy a smooth transition. 
 
Read Reviews
12 min read

Understanding Credit-Based Insurance Scores

Apr 22, 2025 by CJ Hutsenpiller

Shopping for insurance in Tennessee can be tricky – especially when you learn that your credit history can influence...
13 min read

A First Time Homebuyer's Guide to Homeowner's Insurance

Apr 17, 2025 by CJ Hutsenpiller

As a first-time homebuyer in Tennessee, understanding your home insurance is crucial. Not only do you need to choose...
2 min read

E&O Insurance for Small Business in Tennessee

Apr 16, 2025 by CJ Hutsenpiller

As a small business owner in Tennessee, you work hard to serve your clients well. But what happens if one mistake or...
 

Come see us in Mt. Juliet or Gallatin!

Want to stop by? We have physical offices located in Mt. Juliet & Gallatin, TN. 

Mt. Juliet - Inside Vintage Station

2093 N Mt. Juliet Rd
Mt. Juliet TN 37122

Gallatin - Just off the square

170 W Franklin Street
Gallatin, TN 37066