We are independent, experienced, local, responsive, innovative, real people
Independent. Experienced. Always on Your Side.
At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we’re not tied to just one insurance company—we’re independent, and that means we work for you, not the carriers. Our independence is your advantage: we shop the market, compare policies, and advocate for the coverage that fits your life (and your budget), not some corporate quota.
As an independent agency, we’re not tied to one insurance company. We shop around and advocate for what’s best for you, every single time
Client-First Service
You’re never just a number here. Our team is dedicated to personal service and building relationships that last for years.
Technology That Works
From digital quotes to online policy management, we use the latest tools to make your insurance experience quick and painless.
Local Expertise
We live and work in Mt. Juliet, just like you. Our knowledge of the area means smarter coverage and advice you can actually use.
Responsive When It Matters
Insurance emergencies don’t wait for office hours, and neither do we. Our team is ready to help when you need it most, whether it’s a claim or a question.
Trusted since 1992
We’ve been serving Tennessee families and businesses for over 30 years. When you work with us, you get experience and integrity you can count on.
The difference is our people. Meet our team
CJ Hutsenpiller
Agency Owner
Shea Hutsenpiller Director of Compensation
Tanner Sandel
Director of Client Experience
Jessica Davidson
Insurance Agent
Madison McNeese
Insurance Agent
Caetie Page
Insurance Agent
Eric Henry
Insurance Agent
Tyler Allen Insurance Agent
Camilo Arango
Insurance Agent
Kenzie Hammock
Insurance Agent
Rebekah Wallace
Commercial Lines Team Lead
Marie Freels
Client Experience Team - Agent
Jordan Kilgore
Client Experience Team - Agent
Cindy Moses
Client Experience Team
Ciarra Ballinger
Client Experience Team
Megan Brothers
Client Experience Team
Edwin Orozco
Client Experience Team
Jayzee Teczon
Sales Team Assistant
What do we cover? Pretty much Everything.
We’re not just here for your car or your house—we’ve got your whole world covered. From the essentials like auto, home, and life insurance, to the fun stuff and investments—think watercraft, travel trailers, ATVs, business coverage, and investment properties. Whatever you care about, we know how to protect it.
Auto Insurance
Protection that moves with you. Stay on the road with coverage that actually fits your driving life.
Home Insurance
Safeguard your sanctuary. We protect your house, your stuff, and your peace of mind.
Life Insurance
Because your family’s future matters. Coverage that takes care of them, even when you can’t.
Business Insurance
Built for local business owners. Shield your livelihood from life’s “what-ifs.”
Boat Insurance
Make waves, not worries. Coverage for your boat, jet ski, or anything that floats.
Camper Insurance
Hit the open road with confidence. Protect your home away from home, wherever adventure calls.
ATV Insurance
Take the trail, not the risk. Coverage for your four-wheeler, side-by-side, or off-road toys.
Investment Properties
Grow your portfolio, not your headaches. Keep your rentals and real estate assets protected.
