Meet Your Local Expert, Local Agent, Policy Pro
At Hutsenpiller Insurance

A Partnership Built on Trust—Benchmark Realty & Hutsenpiller Insurance

At Hutsenpiller Insurance, we believe buying a home should come with more confidence and less confusion. That’s why we’ve teamed up with Benchmark Realty—one of Tennessee’s most respected real estate brands. Like us, Benchmark is built on trust, transparency, and a reputation for treating people like people, not transactions.

Get A Quote
salesteamvback
 

Here is the deal...

When you work with a Benchmark Realty agent, you don’t just get a great guide to your next home. You get an entire support team, including a dedicated Hutsenpiller Insurance agent—to help you protect your investment from day one. We’re here to make sure you’re covered for all the what-ifs life can throw your way (and let’s be honest, in Tennessee, we’ve seen just about everything).

This partnership is about more than paperwork. It’s about seamless communication between your real estate and insurance teams, proactive advice at every turn, and the peace of mind that comes from knowing your biggest purchase is in trusted hands.

So whether you’re closing on your dream home or just curious about your options, we’re ready to walk with you—every step, every milestone, every question. Just don’t ask us to pick a favorite between Benchmark’s closing gifts and our own insurance swag. Some things are just too close to call.

benchmark
heartemoji
Personalized Solutions

Get coverage tailored to your needs.  Every client is different—we take the time to understand your situation and find the best fit from top-rated carriers.
mindblown
Expert Guidance

Our agents know the local market and provide clear advice, so you never have to guess about your coverage.
flex emoji
Claims Advocacy

We’re with you when it matters most. If you ever have a claim, our team walks you through every step, making sure you get the support you deserve
party emoji
Community Focused

Trusted in Middle Tennessee for over 30 years. As a local, independent agency, we’re committed to our community—because we live here, too.
Learn More About Hutsenpiller

What do we cover? Pretty much Everything.

We’re not just here for your car or your house—we’ve got your whole world covered. From the essentials like auto, home, and life insurance, to the fun stuff and investments—think watercraft, travel trailers, ATVs, business coverage, and investment properties. Whatever you care about, we know how to protect it. 
Auto Insurance

Protection that moves with you. Stay on the road with coverage that actually fits your driving life.
Home Insurance

Safeguard your sanctuary. We protect your house, your stuff, and your peace of mind.
Life Insurance

Because your family’s future matters. Coverage that takes care of them, even when you can’t.
Business Insurance

Built for local business owners. Shield your livelihood from life’s “what-ifs.”
Boat Insurance

Make waves, not worries. Coverage for your boat, jet ski, or anything that floats.
Camper Insurance

Hit the open road with confidence. Protect your home away from home, wherever adventure calls.
ATV Insurance

Take the trail, not the risk. Coverage for your four-wheeler, side-by-side, or off-road toys.
Investment Properties

Grow your portfolio, not your headaches. Keep your rentals and real estate assets protected.
Benchmark agents don’t just refer Hutsenpiller, they rely on them personally, trusting their own homes and families to the same team they recommend to clients.
Scott Rowland
Scott Rowland
President, Benchmark Realty
Screenshot 2025-07-22 at 1.17.19 PM

Bethany McKay
Benchmark Agent

I am amazed by what CJ and his team have done for our family. They made transitioning our insurance so easy and not to mention saved us $1400 in annual insurance!! Highly recommend them. Great customer service. Thank you Hutsenpillar Insurance.

Screenshot 2025-07-23 at 3.24.55 PM

Randy Bernal
Benchmark Agent

As a Realtor I am always looking for industry professionals I can work with but more importantly trust. Very knowledgeable and quick turnaround on any communications.

rick blair

Rick Blair
Benchmark Agent


I have been a customer of Hutsenpiller Insurance for almost a decade now. C.J. and staff are personable, professional and extremely efficient. By switching all of my insurance coverage to Hutsenpiller, I was able to save thousands of dollars per year.

Want to learn more about insurance? Check out our blog.
7 min read
How to Insure Your Engagement Ring in Tennessee: A Newlywed’s Guide

Oct 27, 2025

Hello there! I’m Madi McNeese Tisdale, an insurance agent at Hutsenpiller Insurance and a newlywed myself. Having just...
19 min read
What Type of Life Insurance Do I Need?

Sep 5, 2025

What Type of Life Insurance Do I Need for My Family in Tennessee? Are you a young parent in Nashville, Mt. Juliet,...
14 min read
Escrow Accounts and Midterm Insurance Changes: A guide for Homeowners

Aug 5, 2025

Buying a home in Tennessee comes with a lot of new terminology – one of those terms is an escrow account. If you have a...

Amazing Insurance Agents, Better People.

Want to see what sets Hutsenpiller Insurance apart? It’s our people. Meet the rest of our team and discover the friendly experts who make protecting your world their top priority. Every agent brings something unique to the table—and when you work with us, you get the support of the entire Hutsenpiller family. Click below to learn more about the faces behind your coverage.

Meet Our Team
We represent dozens of
top insurance companies
travelers Nationwide-Insurance-Logo yjyt kpko openly logo

Need help? Let's chat! 💬